How to Prioritize Agile Stories
New to story mapping? Start with our complete User Story Mapping Guide.
Prioritize by what someone can do next
Prioritization usually means ranking features by business value, effort, or votes. That produces an ordered list. It does not produce a first release that leaves a person more capable than they were.
A problem-based approach gets you closer. Aim it at what Kathy Sierra named the suck threshold — the point where someone has invested enough to care and is still bad enough to quit — and it gets you the rest of the way.
The mistake
Teams guess at priority, build solutions for problems nobody has, or optimize for speed to market while the core path still fails. Overbuilding is the same error at a different altitude: depth for people who already succeeded.
Prioritize in this order
- Name the user and the job. One person, one goal. If you can’t, you’re prioritizing a portfolio, not a journey.
- Find where they already invested and still fail. Support tickets, drop-offs, workarounds. A map turns these into visible columns.
- Put the first slice through those columns. The shortest complete path to a first real success.
- Then rank what’s left by value, effort, risk, or learning, inside the later slices.
Business goals, competitive landscape, and budget still matter. They constrain which journeys you attempt. They shouldn’t reorder a slice so that the step where people are stuck gets postponed for depth only your happiest users will notice.
On the map
“Prioritize last” is half right. Structure first, then prioritize inside slices.
- Backbone: the sequence of the job
- Vertical order under an activity: what that step needs to be real
- Horizontal slice: what ships together so the journey still works
Voting and estimation matrices settle conflicts inside a slice. They’re a poor substitute for asking whether a band of work moves someone past can’t.
The test
If your priority order delayed the step where people feel stupid, in favor of something only successful users would ever reach, you didn’t prioritize. You protected the roadmap from the journey.
Ready to try CardBoard for yourself? Create a free account — three boards, no credit card.
Didn’t find what you need? Visit our Help Center to find answers or get in contact with our team.